RatingsMatchGet matched

Best Homeowners Insurance in Placentia, CA

Updated October 2026 · Our Recommended Top 17

  • ✓Licensing
  • ✓User Reviews
  • ✓Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Placentia homeowners insurance on more than 25 variables across five categories and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

20
Reviewed
›
18
Curated
›
17
Top Picks
Learn about our selection process.

= Featured Provider

Featured provider

RatingsMatch Concierge

Best Homeowners Insurance Agency matching for Placentia

Not sure which homeowners insurance agency to call? Tell us the job. We check the shortlist above against your timeline and budget and connect you with the right one, free.

Mon–Fri 6am–4pm PT · Operated by BaaDigi

1

Acceptance Insurance

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

1045 E Imperial Hwy, Brea, CA 92821

RatingsMatch Rating· 43/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation19/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.9 (654)

2

Apollo Insurance Services

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

1040 E Imperial Hwy Ste F3, Brea, CA 92822

RatingsMatch Rating· 43/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation19/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.9 (338)

3

Westways Insurance

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

770 S Brea Blvd #107, Brea, CA 92821

RatingsMatch Rating· 42/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation18/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.8 (234)

4

Sylvia Nye - State Farm Insurance Agent

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

1290 N Kraemer Blvd Ste a, Placentia, CA 92870

sylvianye.comMap
RatingsMatch Rating· 40/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation16/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.8 (83)

7

Minnick Insurance

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

4622 Plumosa Dr, Yorba Linda, CA 92886

RatingsMatch Rating· 40/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation16/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 5.0 (37)

8

Novashield Insurance Agency

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

RatingsMatch Rating· 39/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation15/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 5.0 (29)

9

Scott Lennen - State Farm Insurance Agent

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

1132 E Yorba Linda Blvd, Placentia, CA 92870

RatingsMatch Rating· 36/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation12/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 5.0 (8)

10

Yorba Linda Insurance Services Inc

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

4848 Lakeview Ave #201D, Yorba Linda, CA 92886

RatingsMatch Rating· 36/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation12/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.8 (16)

11

Eric Lopez: Allstate Insurance

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

101 S Kraemer Blvd #218, Placentia, CA 92870

RatingsMatch Rating· 35/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation11/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.3 (56)

12

Tepa Insurance Services

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

213 S State College Blvd, Anaheim, CA 92806

RatingsMatch Rating· 35/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation11/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.6 (17)

13

Jennifer Lamb Insurance Agency

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

949 Williams Ave, Placentia, CA 92870

RatingsMatch Rating· 34/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation10/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 5.0 (3)

14

Nationwide Insurance: Paul Nicholas Kinan

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

1204 E Yorba Linda Blvd, Placentia, CA 92870

RatingsMatch Rating· 33/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation9/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.5 (6)

15

Rhonda Shader - State Farm Insurance

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

151 N Kraemer Blvd #123, Placentia, CA 92870

RatingsMatch Rating· 33/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation9/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 5.0 (2)

16

MultiCo Insurance Solutions

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

747 S Brea Blvd Ste 33, Brea, CA 92821

RatingsMatch Rating· 33/100Show details
  • Availability20/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation9/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.3 (18)

17

Registration & Insurance Services

Best Homeowners Insurance Serving Placentia

303 N Placentia Ave Ste F, Fullerton, CA 92831

Map
RatingsMatch Rating· 32/100Show details
  • Availability15/20
  • Licensing & credentials—
  • Reputation13/20
  • Experience4/20
  • Phone callNot yet shopped

Review sources · Google 4.9 (18)

How does RatingsMatch choose the best homeowners insurance in Placentia?

We pull every homeowners insurance agency we can find serving Placentia, then score each on five things: availability and service area, licensing and credentials, reputation across review sites, experience, and how they handle a real phone call. Only the top scorers make the list. Featured Providers pay for placement and are labeled; scores are never for sale.

Is it free to use the RatingsMatch Concierge?

Yes. Call or send the form and we match you with a homeowners insurance agency from this list at no cost. Featured Providers may pay RatingsMatch for placement, which is why they are labeled.

How does a homeowners insurance agency get listed?

Listings are earned, not bought. Claim your business at https://www.ratingsmatch.com/claim to correct details and add services. Featured placement is a separate paid option that never changes a rating.